The Archetype Misconception

Every few months, I hear someone define archetypes as a brand voice and it makes my soul leave my body. It goes on a lil' journey to find a very stabby sword juuuuust in case we fight. 

It used to be that I wanted to attack, but these days, it's more an act of defense.

Because that idea is not helpful for copywriters.

Usually it's a marketing pro or or someone from a branding agency saying something like this: "the best way to define a brand voice is with an archetype." They say choosing one of the twelve options will clarify your sound.

Oh, I have thoughts...

 

Jung's Dirty Dozen: What Are Brand Archetypes?

Now, when I say "archetype" I'm talking about the 12-sided personality pantheon from Carl Jung: The Outlaw, Creator, Magician, Hero, Lover, Jester, Everyman, Caregiver, Ruler, Innocent, Sage, and Explorer.

They're commonly tied to brands like this:  

Brand Archetypes

(Via March Branding)

The examples vary between countries and years, but you can see how these twelve characteristics can reflect a brand.

And they're not "wrong" per se...

Archetypes have value. They do.

But they are not, I repeat, not a brand voice.

Because they're based on actions. They're based on how people behave, not banter.

Demeaner, not dialog. Tasks, not talk. Purpose, not prose.

Yet like a fortune cookie, archetypes are just specifically vague enough to make marketers think they're perfect.

Why Archetypes Fail As Voice

But here’s the problem...

Archetypes aren’t voices. They’re personalities. They’re characters. They’re based on actions, outcomes, motives, desires, experiences, and very often appearance.

You gonna tell me every "lover" you've had sounded the same?

 

guy eating a rose

(I don't know what this guy sounds like, but I bet he talks with his mouth full)

And let's look at The Sage.

In stories, sages are portrayed as moldy bros and brosephines with long flowy robes and snowdrift hair. Some wear wizard hats. Some are doctors, aristocrats, or professors… or just solitary smarties who are often a little "off." 

In The Hunger Games it was a drunk dude who didn’t want any part of the story. In Star Trek it was a pointy-eared bowl cut who made emotionless decisions.

"Sage" might tell you who they are, but it tells you bupkis about how they speak.

For brands, sage usually means "A Truth-seeker."

But that could mean anything from divine enlightenment all the way down to accessible information. Google makes it simple, Harvard makes it elite. One speaks in doodles, the other speaks in Latin.

You could write a sage brand as a majestic (wo)man on the mountain speaking in riddles and rhymes who imparts wisdom by guiding you rather than giving you a direct answer. But if you lower the vocabulary, you wind up with the Cheshire Cat.

Drop the syntax in a cement mixer and you land on Yoda.

Sage means someone who gives advice — but it doesn’t say a damn thing about how they impart that advice.

The Yoda Effect: When Voice Transcends Character

Remember Yoda’s backward speech? That was all Frank Oz. The original script was more formal and elegant, reminiscent of what you later saw in the prequel’s Jedi Council

Yet the script for Empire had one line — one — written strangely that Oz (the voice and puppeteer of Yoda) grabbed onto and scaled across the character.

 

a pug dressed as Yoda

(Dog or dog not. There is no pie.)

Oz built that character into something better. He built the voice.  

But please realize...

Frank Oz didn’t just "know it when he saw it."

He saw it because he knew it.

And nobody else did.

Oz knew what to look for, how to change it, how to apply it, how to tinker, and how to bring the voice to life so it could grow and evolve into a defining trait of the character.

Not just what he did or said, but… how he said it.

Lucas create the archetype, Oz created the voice: an alien who "sounded alien while still technically speaking English."

Oz took it deeper. He knew the math to build the motive.

Going Beyond Archetypes in Your Copy

As a writer, ya gotta go beyond archetypes.

But in order to do that…

Ya gotta know what you’re looking at and what your client is looking for — because it’s the only way you’ll know what they’re seeing. And it’s the only way to deliver what they want. 

That’s a complex paragraph. Might wanna read it twice.

What I’m saying is… ya gotta be able to identify specifically what your clients are aiming for so you’re not just splorking synonyms from WordHippo and praying to the grammar gods that you guessed right.

You have to know it — and they have to know it — or you might never make ‘em happy.

Just another keyboard monkey hoping to type the collected works of Shakespeare within your two rounds of contracted edits.

 

GIF from the Simpsons with a monkey almost typing the works of Shakespeare

(Good thing this isn't German. Their captions are the wurst.)

The Real Elements of Brand Voice

Archetypes are fine. They're fine. FINE, I SAY!

If you have a client who likes 'em? Cool. I've included plenty in my voice guides. It's no sin. 

But ya gotta go deeper and figure out what it sounds like. And what it looks like on paper.

Archetypes might have value. They're just not voice.

Vocabulary. Tone. Cadence. That's voice.

It’s the difference between:

  • Intent without dedicated action is simply not enough
  • Do or do not. There is no try
  • Shit or get off the pot

‘Cuz those lines are all the same, yet completely different.

Right?

And by analyzing the vocabulary, tone, and cadence, now we can define exactly why.

 

Finding the Sweet Spot: Using Archetypes as a Starting Point

Brand archetypes can absolutely be a good starting point. I'm not opposed to them. They're fine for marketers. They're fine for a 5,000-foot view. 

But unless you understand ‘zactly what your client is looking for and how to bring it alive on the ground level... it's gonna be a frustrating day.

This is the stuff we teach in Write Like Anyone.

And there's way more to it than this.

Metaphors be with you,

Justin


P.S. Once you hit a certain level as a writer, learning voice isn’t just "nice to have."

It's how you own your role.

Star Wars - I like the sound of that

  (Me too, Han. Me too.)

 

Oh, hey... if you're new around here, I'm Justin Blackman and I talk a lot about brand voice and copywriting. If you dig this type of nerdy content, you're gonna love my emails.

Hop on.