What I'm about to say will go against most of what you see on LinkedIn, and I swear I'm not just saying this for the likes.
(Because this is a blog and it has no algorithm.)
You might not agree with it… but I'm 99% sure I'm right. And I have the receipts to justify this claim.
"Should you maintain a consistent voice across channels?"
Let's quickly define "channels" as platforms like:
- Videos
- Websites
- Social media
- SMS communications
...and all the places you show up.
(For more about what a brand voice actually is, check out this post here)
Now, search the internet and you'll find countless answers that sound good in theory but will cause some major problems in practice.
I'm talking about advice like, "it’s imperative that your voice doesn’t change between channels so you build trust." Or "Aside from formatting for various platforms, your voice shouldn’t waver."
Wrong.
Just wrong.
Look, what I'm about to say will either seem obvious or groundbreaking to you… so apologies if you already know this. But clearly enough people don’t.
Your voice should adapt across channels.
That’s how you make a well-rounded and empathetic brand. Because even if you’re formal, nobody wants to talk to the guy wearing a suit at the beach.

(Entrepreneurs be like, "Hashtag Casual Fridays!")
This goes for chill brands too.
Need an example? I thought you'd never ask.
A few weeks back, I had to buy contact lenses, so I checked out 1-800-Contacts, a cool brand with a very cool voice.
They’ve got fun words on their site like, "enter your email and save some moolah… super convenient… gajillion percent happiness promise."
Those are great lines! I love this! Plus, they’re one of the rare few who do the CD Baby email in a non-cringe way.
But read their online reviews and what do you find? The biggest complaint is their customer service. And not for the reasons you think.
See, if you’re contacting customer support, it's because you have a problem. (Duh.) And since contacts aren’t cheap, this problem is likely costing you between $200-$500.
That’s not nothing.
So I ask you, for that price, do you want some chill, emoji-slingin’ silly boi helping you? Or do you want a grown-ass adult you trust to take care of the problem?
I’ll tell ya that dozens of complaints mentioned the "lax attitude" of customer support — some even citing the lack of punctuation or capital letters as a major turn-off.
(I could swear there was a How I Met Your Mother "Major Turn-Off" GIF to drop here, but Google says no.)
When you contact support, you want precision. You want empathy. You want consideration. You want a semblance of discipline, manners, and respect… and you expect competency in the person to genuinely be able to help you.
This should be general knowledge.

(Close Enough)
Do you see how "committing to the bit" is the problem here? Do you see how maintaining consistency is not helping?
So maybe they drop the chillness. Or maybe they address the concern with a little on-brand humor then assure us that all will be taken care of. But make sure the customer is heard.
In this situation, "maintaining a consistent brand voice across all channels" is biting them in the butt.
Your voice can and should flex depending on the situation.
The same Soccer Mom who packs juice boxes for the team and cheers loudest on the sideline will also throat punch anyone who trips their kid.
Different situations call for different voices.
Look, I could go on about how a well-defined voice guide will document how you carry this out — and they will. And yes, you can absolutely find fun ways to maintain a silly voice in customer support channels — but it takes tact! And you have to bend.
I wrote an email for a candy company where we blamed lost orders on aliens. We pegged incorrect shipments on an octopus. We maintained a high level of silliness throughout the encounter, but…
We also assured customers they were in good hands and would be taken care of.
People want to be seen.
And if your brand’s ego gets in the way and commitment to a quirk outshines your customer needs?
That’s not gonna end well.
Sometimes you have to sacrifice voice in favor values. Commit to who you are above how you sound. That should be your guiding light. The voice will follow, and if something gets in its way, it will adjust.
This is the way.
If you don't believe me, just read the reviews.
Oh, and if you're new around here, I'm Justin Blackman and I talk a lot about brand voice and copywriting. If you dig this kinda stuff, you should totes get my emails.

